1:1 Macro with Extension tubes

2008-07-28
After I tried the Vivitar AT-22 extension tubes with my Pentax A 50mm f/2.8 1:2 Macro with 20mm extension, I try it again this morning with my Pentax K 100mm f/4.0 1:2 Macro. It is extremely difficult if NOT impossible to do hand-holding.

Pentax K 100mm f/4.0 1:2 Macro
Vivitar AT-22 extension tubes

Pentax K 100mm f/4.0 1:2 Macro + Vivitar AT-22 Macro extension tubes 12mm + 36mm extension tubesExtension tubes used: 36+12=48mm
No sharpening applied in pp;
all are hand-held in iso 400


#1
Pentax K 100mm f/4.0 1:2 Macro + Vivitar AT-22 Macro extension tubes 12mm + 36mm extension tubes

#2
Pentax K 100mm f/4.0 1:2 Macro + Vivitar AT-22 Macro extension tubes 12mm + 36mm extension tubes
#3
Pentax K 100mm f/4.0 1:2 Macro + Vivitar AT-22 Macro extension tubes 12mm + 36mm extension tubes
#4
Pentax K 100mm f/4.0 1:2 Macro + Vivitar AT-22 Macro extension tubes 12mm + 36mm extension tubes
#5

Pentax K 100mm f/4.0 1:2 Macro + Vivitar AT-22 Macro extension tubes 12mm + 36mm extension tubes

When I turn my focus to the minimum closest distance with marking at 1:2 ratio, I have an extremely difficult time to obtain focus in 1:1, but when I turn slightly to 1:2.5 or 1:2.2 minimal focusing distance, I find focus feasible as compared to 1:1 with the extension tubes. The closer to 1:1, the harder it is to obtain focus, perhaps due to the razor thin DOF.

With two different shoot out, I have to say that the extension tubes are good to retain bokeh, flare control and CA control with the lens with no addition of optical elements. But I find 100mm is too difficult for me to do hand-holding without tripod whereas 50mm is a bit easier to obtain focus for me.

Impressions & Notes:
  • It is much harder to do hand holding with extension tubes on 100mm as compared to 50mm
  • The closer I am with 1:2 original marking on macro lens with extension tube on, I find it extremely difficult if NOT impossible to focus.
  • 1:1 macro is difficult to do without tripod
  • Extension Tubes continue to benefit with no optical elements, flare control as well as CA are well within the limits of the lens used
  • My 100mm usually stay about a foot from closest distance and with the extension tubes, that advantage of having a good distance in shooting bugs is lost
  • Bokeh seems unchanged with the use of extension tubes
  • In practice, I don't seem to be able to shoot in 1:1 at the 1:2 marking on my 100mm macro lens. I end up shooting most of my test shots in 1:2.2 and 1:2.5 marking.
Related:

0 comments:

Post a Comment

 

About

Welcome to Hin's Photo Corner, this is my learning blog on photography, blogging and advertising. And I hope you enjoy your visit. For contact, please comment in blog post or email me directly hintheman at gmail.com.

 

B&H Best Deals

Statcounter